Are you debating between a Belgian Malinois and a German Shepherd as a potential new pet? This article will provide a detailed comparison of these two fantastic dog breeds so that you can make an informed decision. Everything from their outward appearance to their personality and their amenability to instruction will be discussed. Relax with a cup of coffee in hand and listen as I pit the Belgian Malinois against the German Shepherd in an imaginary fight.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd History and Origin?
The Belgian Malinois is a canine breed that originated in Belgium and is a direct offspring of the Belgian Shepherd Dog. The breed was originally developed for the purpose of protecting livestock. In 1959, the Belgian Malinois gained official recognition from the American Kennel Club.
The original German herding dog was developed in Germany in the 1870s, from which the modern German Shepherd breed evolved. The breed was originally developed for the purpose of protecting livestock. The German Shepherd was officially recognised by the American Kennel Club in 1908.
The strength, intellect, and loyalty of these breeds are well-known traits. Both are great options for anyone seeking for a new family pet.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd comparison
Here are detailed table comparison between Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd
| Trait | Belgian Malinois | German Shepherd |
|---|---|---|
| Breed Size | Medium-Large | Large |
| Height | 22-26 inches (male) | 24-26 inches (male) |
| 22-24 inches (female) | 22-24 inches (female) | |
| Weight | 60-80 pounds (male) | 65-90 pounds (male) |
| 40-60 pounds (female) | 50-70 pounds (female) | |
| Coat Type | Short, straight | Double, medium-length |
| Coat Color | Fawn, mahogany, | Black, tan, black and |
| black, and brindle | red, sable | |
| Life Span | 12-14 years | 9-13 years |
| Temperament | Intelligent, | Intelligent, |
| energetic, | loyal, protective | |
| protective | ||
| Trainability | Easy to train | Easy to train |
| Exercise Needs | High | High |
| Health Concerns | Hip dysplasia, | Hip dysplasia, |
| elbow dysplasia, | elbow dysplasia, | |
| progressive retinal | degenerative myelopathy, | |
| atrophy, and bloat | bloat | |
| Popularity Rank | #60 (AKC, 2021) | #2 (AKC, 2021) |
Male German Shepherds average 26 inches in height at the shoulder, while females are significantly smaller at 24 inches. The shoulder height of male Belgian Malinois is 24 inches, while that of females is 22 inches. A strong back, muscular legs, and a deep chest are characteristics shared by both breeds.
The German Shepherd is known for its thick double coat, which may be anything from medium to long in length. Both the undercoat and the outer coat are thick and dense, but the undercoat is softer and fluffier.
This coat protects them from the sun and the cold. The single coat on a Belgian Malinois is shorter and finer, so it lies close to the dog’s body. Their coat doesn’t keep out the elements as well as a German Shepherd’s does, but it needs less maintenance.
The skulls of German Shepherds and other large breeds are broad and spherical, while the skulls of Belgian Malinois are narrow and long. The eyes of both German Shepherds and Belgian Malinois are brown, but the latter have the almond shape of a German Shepherd.
The Belgian Malinois is livelier and more jovial than the German Shepherd, which is more serious and reserved. Ultimately, meeting both sorts of dogs and seeing which one you connect with the most is the greatest method to pick which breed is ideal for you.
When compared to the German Shepherd, the Belgian Malinois is the healthier option. Most Belgian Malinois suffer from hip dysplasia, a condition that can make them lame and painful. However, unlike in German Shepherds, this condition is much less common in Belgian Malinois. Belgian Malinois can also develop problems like elbow dysplasia, epilepsy, and allergies.
Although German Shepherds share the same robust health as Belgian Malinois, they are more prone to a few specific ailments. The most prevalent health problem in German Shepherds is hip dysplasia, which can result in lameness and pain in the hips.
The Belgian Malinois, on the other hand, is a medium-energy breed that can get by with less activity than the German Shepherd. This suggests that the German Shepherd is a good choice if you want a dog that is simple to teach. Yet, if you put in the time and effort, a Belgian Malinois may be just as obedient as any other breed.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd Pros and cons
The comparison of pros and cons of German shepherd vs Belgian Malinois is given below-
Brussels Malinois Pros-
One, it’s easy to train a Belgian Malinois because they’re so smart. Also, they are very submissive.
Second, Belgian Malinois are loyal and watchful companions. They serve as trustworthy guard dogs.
Third, because of their high levels of energy, Belgian Malinois need extensive daily exercise. They need space to run about and play, such as a backyard or access to a park.
Brussels Malinois Cons:
Because of their strong sense of territory, some dogs may not get along with Belgian Malinois. These could be too stimulating for younger kids.
Second, Belgian Malinois need regular grooming because of their thick coat. They also tend to shed a lot.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd- which is best for you?
These are some important comparisons between the two breeds:
The Belgian Malinois is a medium-sized breed, whereas the German Shepherd is on the larger side. The German Shepherd is an excellent choice if a large dog is desired. The smaller Belgian Malinois may be more practical if you have a small flat or otherwise restricted living quarters.
The German Shepherd may be the more active of the two breeds, but both need a lot of exercise. Either breed is a wonderful choice if you want to go on lengthy walks or runs. The Belgian Malinois is an option if you’d like have something low-key as a pet.
Both breeds are known for their protective nature, but the Belgian Malinois is often employed in law enforcement and the armed forces as a working dog because of its high level of drive.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd comparison- who will win?
The German Shepherd is larger and heavier than the Belgian Malinois, which could give it the upper hand in a fight between the two breeds. Ultimately, the outcome of the fight would depend on the dogs themselves.
Both are highly clever, devoted, and protective canines who would do well in either a home or a professional setting. When well-cared for, both the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd can be wonderful additions to their families, but the former is smaller and has more activity.